Kilowatt-Hours vs Rands – Why cost per kWh matters in solar battery value

When comparing solar battery quotes, the final price often carries the most weight. For many customers, the decision comes down to the figure at the bottom of the page. But does the lowest price always represent the best value? 

As a distributor of various battery storage technologies, we regularly receive requests for batteries with specific storage capacities. This is encouraging. A few years ago, many consumers weren’t familiar with the term kilowatt-hour (kWh). Today, customers are more informed and increasingly know what capacity they want. 

But are we looking at the right numbers when comparing battery prices? 

Looking Beyond Battery Capacity 

With so many battery options on the market, customers often approach installers with a specific battery capacity in mind. As a result, they may overlook other options that offer better value simply because they differ from their original requirements. 

In some cases, minimum battery capacity is a technical requirement. The system needs sufficient storage and discharge capability to meet its intended load demands. However, in an effort to reduce the upfront cost of a solar installation, customers often look for the smallest battery to meets those minimum requirements. 

While this may lower the initial investment, focusing exclusively on minimum capacity can mean overlooking better-value options. 

After all, the objective isn’t simply to purchase a battery of a particular size. It’s to invest in an energy storage system that meets the customer’s needs, performs reliably and delivers value over its operating life. 

Why Battery Cost per kWh Matters 

Battery storage capacity is measured in kilowatt-hours (kWh), which represents the amount of energy a battery can store. 

When comparing battery prices, one of the most useful metrics is the cost per kilowatt-hour (R/kWh). 

The calculation is straightforward: 

Battery cost per kWh = Battery purchase price ÷ Battery capacity (kWh) 

For example, consider two battery options: 

 Battery A Battery B 
Storage capacity 5.12 kWh 8.8 kWh 
Purchase price R15,000 R22,000 
Cost per kWh R2,930 R2,500 
Illustrative pricing only. 

Although Battery B costs more upfront, it offers better value, with a cost per kWh approximately 15% lower than Battery A. 

Several factors influence battery pricing, including manufacturing costs, market demand, technology and product availability. As a result, a larger battery can sometimes offer better value per kWh than a smaller, more popular model. 

The difference may not be dramatic, but it can be significant enough to justify reconsidering the original specification. 

Of course, cost per kWh shouldn’t be the only deciding factor. Usable capacity, inverter compatibility, discharge capability, warranty conditions and expected cycle life also matter. 

The Benefits of a Larger Battery Bank 

Where the system design and budget allow, installing slightly more battery capacity than initially specified can offer several advantages. 

1. More Usable Storage as the Battery Ages 

All batteries gradually lose some of their original capacity through use and ageing. 

Starting with a larger battery bank provides additional storage headroom. As the battery’s capacity declines over time, the system may continue meeting the customer’s energy requirements for longer. 

2. Longer Backup Power During Grid Outages 

A larger battery bank can provide longer autonomy when grid power is unavailable, provided the usable capacity is greater and the connected loads remain the same. 

This gives customers more flexibility during extended outages or periods of low solar production. 

3. More Solar Energy Available for Later Use 

Additional battery capacity allows a system to store more surplus solar energy, provided sufficient PV generation is available. 

Instead of exporting or curtailing excess generation when the battery reaches full charge, the system may be able to retain more energy for evening consumption or peak tariff periods. 

This can improve solar self-consumption and reduce reliance on grid electricity. 

How Battery Capacity Affects Long-Term Performance 

The benefits of additional battery capacity extend beyond the energy available to the customer. They can also affect how hard the battery bank works. 

Consider two battery banks supplying the same daily energy demand. 

A smaller battery bank will generally experience a greater depth of discharge (DoD) than a larger bank delivering the same amount of energy. 

For example, supplying 4kWh from a 5kWh usable battery bank represents an 80% depth of discharge. Supplying the same 4kWh from a 10kWh usable bank represents just 40%. 

For many lithium battery systems, shallower discharge cycles can help reduce battery degradation over time. This means a larger battery bank may retain more of its original capacity as it ages, depending on the battery chemistry and operating conditions. 

There is also the question of current loading and heat generation. 

When additional batteries are connected in parallel, the total load can be distributed across more battery modules. If the batteries share that load evenly, each module supplies less current. 

This matters because electrical resistance generates heat, and the heat produced in a given electrical path increases with the square of the current. 

In practical terms, reducing the current flowing through each battery can reduce resistive losses and heat generation. Lower operating temperatures can, in turn, help limit thermal stress on battery cells and electrical components. 

Battery voltage also plays a role. For a given power demand, higher operating voltage requires less current. However, adding battery capacity does not necessarily increase the system voltage. The result depends on whether batteries are connected in series or parallel and how the system is designed. 

Together, these factors explain why a correctly sized battery bank with sufficient capacity can operate under less demanding conditions than one consistently working close to its limits. 

Over time, this may contribute to better capacity retention, more consistent performance and potentially lower maintenance or replacement costs. 

The important distinction is that a larger battery doesn’t automatically perform better. It creates the opportunity for less demanding operation when the system is correctly designed and configured. 

The Real Cost of Battery Storage 

A battery’s purchase price tells only part of the story. 

The real value of an energy storage system lies in how much usable energy it provides, how well it supports the installation and how reliably it performs over time. 

A smaller battery may cost less upfront, but a larger alternative could offer better value per kWh, more backup capacity and potentially less demanding operating conditions. 

These factors can influence the total cost of ownership. A battery that retains its capacity for longer and continues to meet the site’s energy requirements may delay the need for additional storage or replacement. 

That doesn’t mean bigger is always better. Oversizing a battery bank beyond the site’s energy requirements may add costs without delivering a worthwhile return. 

The goal is to find the right balance between capacity, performance and price. 

Compare Kilowatt-Hours, Not Just Rands 

When assessing battery quotations, the lowest figure at the bottom of the page shouldn’t automatically determine the final decision. 

Compare the cost per kWh. Consider the usable capacity, expected daily cycling, discharge requirements, and future energy needs. Most importantly, assess how the battery will perform as part of the complete solar installation. 

We work with solar installers and EPCs to identify suitable battery storage solutions for residential, commercial, and industrial applications. Our extensive battery portfolio allows us to recommend solutions that meet each project’s capacity, performance, and budget requirements. 

Working on a solar or battery storage project? Share your system requirements with our team, and we’ll help you compare the available options. 

Sales

sales@getoffgrid.co.za
+27 11 791 2348

Technical support

Tech@getoffgrid.co.za
+27 11 791 2348

Support & Resources

© 2024 Get Off Grid. All Rights Reserved.